Board Hears Zoning Appeal
By DAVID QUESENBERRY
Patriot Publishing
The Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) of the Town of Pulaski held a public hearing on Thursday, November 12, 2026 to hear an appeal of an administrative zoning determination regarding the property at 2321 Pleasant Hill Drive made under the Town of Pulaski Zoning Ordinance.
The property (59.17 acres) is split by the corporate boundary between the Town (13.99 acres) and the County (45 acres). The appeal was filed by Horner Acre Farms, L.L.C., Grant and Rebecca Horner, owners, concerning an administrative zoning compliance letter regarding an agricultural business on the portion of their property zoned R-1 within the Town’s corporate limits.
According to the notice of violation letter issued by Zoning Administrator Nathan Smythers on October 3, 2025, the property appeared to be used for an agricultural business operation. The property was located in the Town’s R-1 Single-Family Residential District which is intended for low-density residential use.
The compliance letter stated that business operations and signage were not permitted activities in the R-1 District and stated that “the current use of the property does not comply with the Town of Pulaski Zoning Ordinance.”
The letter also stated that although the County told the Horners that in the County certain agricultural uses could be continued as a non-conforming use, under the Town’s zoning code, non-conforming uses, even if they were already in place, could not be expanded to include new buildings and structures.
The agricultural business was “not authorized by any pre-existing non-conforming use, if one exists.” To remedy the violation, business activity would have to be stopped and the non-conforming structure, the farm store, removed.
The Horner’s in their response gave three reasons for their appeal to the BZA.
First, they maintained that Mr. Smythers, the Zoning Administrator, misinterpreted the Town’s zoning ordinance as they apply to the agricultural use of the property.
Second, before their farm store building was built they consulted with Tim Hale, the Town Building Inspector at the time, if a building permit was needed. In their letter, they stated that they were told clearly that no permit was required since their proposed structure fell within an “agricultural exemption.” At no time did Hale advise them that a building could not be built. Based on this information from a Town Building Official, the Horners expended thousands of dollars in construction of the farm store building now in question. They state they relied in good faith on that information and that the Town should be estopped from asserting their building is in violation of the zoning regulations.
Thirdly, the Horners asserted in their letter of appeal that non-conforming and permitted uses had been inconsistently applied, pointing the existence of a businesses at the end of Pleasant Hill Drive in the R-1 zone and the B-1 zoning of a parcel a couple of hundred feet from their property.
Mr. Smythers responded to the assertions. Concerning the claim that the zoning ordinance was misinterpreted as applied to agricultural use structures, he noted the property was not zoned agricultural under the Town zoning ordinance. He said that the Town had not issued a determination establishing a lawful non-conforming agricultural use of the property. Finally, he noted if a non-conforming use did exist, the Zoning Ordinance prohibits the expansion or intensification of non-conforming use. Furthermore, no structure that was not conforming to the ordinance could be built.
Concerning the claim that the Building Official indicated there was an agricultural exemption for construction of the building, Smythers noted that while the Building Official may have been correct about exemptions for agricultural buildings, a building permit exemption did not give an exemption from zoning compliance with the Town’s ordinance. Concerning inconsistent application of permitted and non-conforming uses, Smythers said concerning the two properties mentioned in the appeal letter, the Town had not issued a determination of a non-conforming use nor was it aware of any expansion, intensification, or change in operation for either property. Based on these points, Smythers requested the Board uphold the Town’s Zoning Ordinance based on the ordinance’s provisions for non-conforming uses of land.
Attorney Mike Barbour, representing the Horners, said both the Town and County sections of the parcel had always been used for agriculture for many years prior and therefore an agricultural use was grandfathered in. This agricultural use was verified by documents requested under the Freedom of Information Act along with information from previous owners.
There was no question whatsoever, he said, that this property was grandfathered in for agriculture. The land use valuation for agriculture had been established repeatedly by documents filed with the Commissioner of Revenue noting that the property had been used for farming.
He emphasized that the Horners would not have purchased this property he said, if they had any doubt that the entire property was not grandfathered for agriculture. They would not have constructed their farm store given the amount of financial investment made he said, if they thought it was unlawful Barbour told the Board that what was abundantly clear from the records that government officials were actively involved in assisting the Horners.
He noted the involvement of the past Building Inspector in permitting utilities as well as conversations on construction of the farm store building where they were told that a building permit was not required.
Conversations were also held with the Zoning Administrator concerning temporary use of a travel trailer as a residence until a permanent home was built. Town records also indicated that several Town officials were actively involved in finding grants for the farm store. It appeared he said, that the farm store was no secret and the officials thought they could do it. Back in 2024, the County EDA awarded a $15,000 grant to the Horners for the farm store and submitted a letter supporting the Town’s effort to secure funding for the store.
All of this activity took place before construction of the store. The store itself was built over a period of several months Barbour observed, but no one told the Horners that they could not build the structure. It was after the fact when the store was completed and opened that a problem with permits was mentioned and shortly after a notice of zoning violation was received.
Barbour said that unequivocally it was the Horners position that the Town should be estopped from claiming they are in violation of the zoning ordinance in light of the Town’s records which showed that assistance and guidance was given by Town officials who were involved with the farm store. Furthermore he said that the construction of the farm store was no secret from local officials.
The Horners relied on what they were told and the actions of government officials. He further questioned the inconsistent enforcement concerning permitted and non-conforming uses, noting that there were two enterprises on Pleasant Hill Drive that had business licenses one of which was in the R-1 Residential Zone. “It’s a mess” said Barbour . “We’re asking you to overrule Mr. Smythers violation notice.”
The Board also received public comment during the hearing. Mark Weikel told the Board he moved to Pleasant Hill Drive thinking he was in one of the Town’s more desirable neighborhoods which his investment would be protected by zoning. He stated there was a reason why the land behind his home was zoned R-1 by previous Town administrators. Allowing “spot” zoning in an area zoned R-1 would set a negative precedent and send a clear message to citizens and outside investors that they would not be protected.
Kevin Meyer, Planning Commission Chairman said he was “surprised, shocked, and appalled” by the Horner Farms situation. He acknowledged that the farm store was constructed within the town limits but with the knowledge of both the Town and County. Utilities were installed for an agricultural building whose construction was monitored by the Town, which he took as tacit approval by the Town through inaction. State code refers to grandfathered agricultural uses that were permitted to include farm stores and the like. He noted that the Council voted against rezoning the property for agricultural use and for allowing a farm store as a special exception. He felt it was time the Town stop “giving itself a black eye.”
Bob Hettrick described the Planning Commission’s take on the situation as a “calamity of errors” which needed to be fixed. The Horners did everything they should have done he said, while everyone in the Town knew what they were doing. He urged the Board to do the “right thing.”
After the public hearing, both Smythers and Barbour made concluding remarks to the Board. Following further discussion, the Board decided to take advantage of the thirty day period allowed to consider the issues discussed during the appeal. The Board voted to reconvene on Thursday, December 10, 2026 at 6:00 pm in the Council Chambers to continue consideration of the appeal and to allow the parties involved time to work toward a resolution of the issue.
